Libby Question...

[notorious1]

Can't find this "theory" in the threads, so if it's been talked about please direct me that way please...

A couple of my obsessed Lost friends have a theory about Libby...

...that she doesn't even exist. Only Hurley can see her, and while others might mention her name, they never have directly spoken TO her.

I say no way. Are there instances in previous shows that can discount this?

Thanks!

[mrfrankie]

Yes, when AL asks if she's a doctor. One of many conversations with tallies in the other 48 days.

[LostInWilderness]

Moving to Libby's forum.

[lostdog]

She talked to Claire when she was trying to remember what happened to her.

[notorious1]

ok thanks... I thought so, just couldn't think of anything to disprove it!

[LPU]

So...Dave has a sister? I doubt it personally, but interesting!

[igator210]

Libby and Ana-Lucia talked when Ana-Lucia was digging the pit for Nathan

[Brian]

From Maternity Leave:

[Kate and Claire approach Libby and Hurley.]

LIBBY: Hey.

HURLEY: Hey, guys.

CLAIRE: So, you're a shrink, right?

LIBBY: I'm a clinical psychologist, but "shrink" works, too.

CLAIRE: Can you help people remember things?

LIBBY: I guess it depends on what you need to remember.

Another example of Libby conversing with the castaways.

(Thanks, spooky for the transcripts!)

[cautiousguyonlost]

How does she REALLY feel for Hurley? Is it an act?