Is everyone just assuming that it was Jacob who spoke to Locke?

[mrBIGstar]

Might it have been Ben who said 'Help Me' to Locke, deliberately trying to make Locke think it was 'Jacob' for some reason?

Now I know that there are screen shots of someone in the chair and I fully support the idea that there WAS someone else there. But there is the possibility that it was Ben who said the words, and not Jacob. I don't know why, but would be interested in your opinions on this and why it may and may not have been Ben.

[Dartwick]

Jacob is just another facade for some black smoke.

[mrBIGstar]

Jacob is just another facade for some black smoke.

Sorry, but i fail to spot the relevance of that post to the original question....
And where is your proof/thoughts which back-up your statement about the smoke?

[DarthKitty]

Actually, before I got up this A.M. and saw the screencaps, I thought it was Ben speaking.

[shoop_puveler]

Jacob brought Cooper back to life and flashed his presence in the chair because he knows Locke did not kill him himself. Cooper said "help me" - he actually IS now in P-word!

Bwahahahahahahahahaha! Last nights epi sent me off the deep end!

[DarthKitty]

:rotfl: at Shoop!! I am in the deep end with you! Craziness!