Richard wasn't at Jacob's house

[Midget]

The way Richard intently questions Ben when Ben returns to the Others' village seems to make it clear that Richard wasn't behind any of the shenanigans at the shrieking shack. So does that lend more creedence to the belief that what happened at Jacob's house really happened?

[traveling wilbury]

why not? his questioning, along with alex's, clearly shows you no one else was involved from the others camp. i haven't seen tom lately, though... hmmmm.

[see you in the next life]

The way Richard intently questions Ben when Ben returns to the Others' village seems to make it clear that Richard wasn't behind any of the shenanigans at the shrieking shack. So does that lend more creedence to the belief that what happened at Jacob's house really happened?


We know that what happened at the shack was real BECAUSE we have seen the screencaps that depict the translucent figure that was actually in the chair.

I think that is the proof.

[Hodgepodge]

Lets merge this with one of the many, 'what went on in Jacob's cabin' threads. Follow the link for continued discussion.


ETA: Instead, I'm going to move it to the Jacob forum.