PDA

View Full Version : Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.


Iseult of the White Hands
10-15-04, 11:50 PM
That's a quote from my favorite author (George RR Martin), BTW, when people start to get really creative about What Will Happen Next in his series.

This is what I think about the island and the plane crash survivors: I think that the island was a scientific installation, possibly developing biological weapons for the French, or perhaps some other, more nefarious agency. They kept animals on the island as research subjects. Then, about 16 years ago, whatever they were working on (a virus, perhaps?) got loose and killed all but one of them.

The message itself- it seems to me that it was meant for someone very specific to hear- someone who would know what "it" is. The message may have been a warning- don't come here- rather than a plea for help.

The plane crash. I think that a random group of people were on a plane that went down in the Pacific. The pilots looked for the nearest land to set down on and that was the island. I'm not really surprised that the passengers have such interesting back stories- in my experience, most planes are full of people with stories to tell. I rather suspect that the purpose of the show is to explore how people react to the situation and one another. A plane is a cross section of a lot of different kinds of people who often never meet or interact even though they are on the same plane, going to the same place.

I think that the "monster" in the trees sounds mechanical because it *is*. I think it's probably a vehicle used by the last survivor of the group from 16 years ago. But as a plot device, it's interesting to see how people react to something they don't know about or understand.

So I know it's not as much fun as time travel and woolly mammoths... but it makes sense to me.

MacLeod
10-16-04, 12:02 AM
WOW that's great!!! Someone should make that into a movie or TV show. :lol

Mac

Yoyodyne - Where the future starts tomorrow.

kaycee13
10-16-04, 12:07 AM
Not that it matters, but that's a Sigmund Freud quote. :D

JacksGirlfriend
10-16-04, 12:12 AM
Iseult: There is every possibility that you're right... but I hope not.

As interesting as these characters are, as complicated as the plot might become, as suspenseful as future episodes might be, I still want more.

JacksGirl

Iseult of the White Hands
10-16-04, 12:17 AM
Did Freud say that first? And here I thought that everything George uttered was new and original. Well. Usually it is... :lol

Stu1961
10-16-04, 03:11 PM
I think that the "monster" in the trees sounds mechanical because it *is*. I think it's probably a vehicle used by the last survivor of the group from 16 years ago. But as a plot device, it's interesting to see how people react to something they don't know about or understand.

How does the pilot being yanked straight up and out of the plane (at a height of approx 30 feet), and killed, work into this scenario? Is it an AT&T telephone company truck with a cherry-picker? Odd sounding horn too. :eek :lol

JacksGirlfriend
10-17-04, 01:01 AM
Iseult: You might enjoy the Leviathan thread.

JacksGirl

Wynter Zera
12-18-04, 04:27 PM
What if the monster were some sort of Military tech? Some stealth something or another? Someone hinted in an interview there were two different "monsters" out there. One black and one white? Organic vs. synthetic?

TheBigCat
12-18-04, 04:39 PM
I think that I agree with Iseult and George "RailRoad" Martin as Asimov called him. The theories are fun, but not as fun as sitting back and seeing what the writers are going to spring next. Too bad that it's gonna be another month before the next new episode. Until then, lets let the theories fly!